By Ruth A. Sheets
I wrote and just sent a letter to my senators and representative for an environmental organization called “Oil Change International.” With their help, this is the letter I sent, modified slightly to specifically fit the person I was writing to. This is sort of the generic version.
What the heck is wrong with members of Congress? There are even doctors among you, probably some who have had family members die of the effects of pollution! The level of either utter ignorance or just plain EVIL is remarkable mostly within Republicana, but some Democrats or folks who claim to be Democrats are involved too. That is a betrayal of the American people and of our planet. There is no money gains or other benefits that would ever excuse such appalling legislation, yet it is being "fast-tracked in our Senate! Again, what the heck is wrong with you all, even the staff members who refuse to let you know how We the People feel about such stupidity are involved. I get it that Trump has a hold on Republicana, but people who know about health and have lived through the past pollution know better and can just say no as Nancy Reagan used to advise.
As you can see, I am writing to you to express my opposition to Congress’s negotiations on so-called “permitting reform.” This is not about real reform! Like all the Republican-named bills, it is exactly opposite of its name, it is about "permitting return," return to the pollution and greed of the past. Who wants that? No one, but you all are either getting paid to go along with it or just don't care about the American people, even your constituents! That is EVIL! People of this nation don't want you to vote for any permitting deal under this Congress or any other. People want you to stop any deal that aids fossil fuel expansion (including subsidies for gas oil or coal), and weakens community engagement and public health analysis, Tribal consultation, transparency, or judicial review.
I get it that Republicana is trying hard to pretend that global warming is not real, but you/everyone knows it is and that we need to stop using fossil fuels really soon. You all went to college and must have taken some basic science courses that would remind you that the earth is a closed environment; what happens here is shared everywhere. It is so shameful to us that China is working harder than we are to stop polluting, particularly when we have the ability to catch up and pass them or actually work with them.
As you know, the “permitting reform” proposals that have been introduced this Congress don’t address the important challenges of reducing energy costs for American families, ending the $35 billion in annual fossil fuel subsidies, or deploying good public infrastructure, including safe and affordable housing, public transportation, and renewable energy or just about anything else. They are designed to bring mor wealth to the already too wealthy. That is unacceptable! These actions weaken bedrock environmental laws like the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, and National Historic Preservation Act that communities depend on, while reducing review processes for dangerous fossil fuel projects. All of those acts were not passed under Democrats, some under Republicans too. One would think even Republicans would have some loyalty to what those who came before them stood and worked for. Republicans have plenty of loyalty to the hates and resentments of the past, maybe instead it’s time to have some loyalty to the positive advances we have made.
You should know that efforts to weaken these safeguards are extremely problematic, given that the Trump Administration has already eroded environmental and public health regulations, and for no good reason but the wealth of the oligarchic buddies of Donald Trump and the donors for many in Congress, does that include you? Such largess is no reason to put our lives at risk due to pollution, including rescinding 80% of NEPA regulations, limiting the waters protected under the Clean Water Act, allowing facilities to construct polluting infrastructure before Clean Air Act permits are granted, and more. Whose idea was this and why are you all, supposedly intelligent people going along with it? Don't you care about your children and grandchildren's future!!
Stripping these environmental and public health protections is already costing people’s lives. The Institute for Policy Integrity, reports Trump’s environmental and public health deregulation is costing 3,299 lives and $156.6 billion in benefits annually. So much for getting rid of waste!
Further deregulation will mean exposure to oil spills, gas leaks, air pollution, water pollution, and premature death in communities burdened by pollution. I get it that many there in Congress are OK with those communities suffering because it appears you think those folks are expendable! Such attitudes are EVIL! Trump’s policies are designed to not support an equitable transition to renewable energy. Trump doesn’t want such a transition because it will mean his oil buddies won’t have the funds to keep him in the cash he craves.
I am guessing you all think you live in your gated neighborhoods and mansions, so won't be impacted by the pollution; that is truly insane. Of course you will, at a lesser risk, but certainly at a higher risk than with those regulations in place. I keep hearing that gutting these environmental protections in this proposal will reduce rising energy costs, it won’t. Recent analysis from Oil Change International shows U.S. wholesale fossil gas prices will likely double by the 2030s if the Trump administration’s energy and AI policies succeed in pushing gas demand to levels that can only be met with more expensive gas production, clearly something that would be bad for everyone, well, except the fossil fuelers.
At this time, when communities across the country are facing environmental and public health rollbacks, loss of healthcare funding, and increasing climate disasters, we must protect and develop stronger environmental and public health protections, not weaken them. It does not take a doctorate in public health and disaster management to understand that. OK, there probably aren’t any holders of such Doctorates in Trumplandia!
I don't expect you to pay any attention to this communication, which is why I am hoping my Republican senators will be voted out of office as soon as possible. You have done nothing for Pennsylvania and as far as I can see, plan to do nothing but work for Donald Trump, an old man with dementia who lives for his vengeance and resentments, displaying his ignorance daily.
Thank you Representative Scanlon for your efforts to stop global warming and have our nation produce more renewable energy. I regret you, My senators, Fetterman and McCormick will not because of your inability to stand with the people and our planet instead of with Donald Trump who cares for no one and nothing but himself. How sad for all of us.
Sincerely,
Rev. Ruth A. Sheets